If you have ever googled the word “collage”, you may have been stunned by the staggering amount of entries (
43,200,000 results) for that word alone (and this without counting all its derivatives). Putting aside the obvious inadequacy of any search engine, it is still possible to stumble upon if not exquisite, at least intriguing, collage art. However, the majority of returns on Google gives you stuff like “Create a celebrity collage,” “Collage.org: A music and dance ministry,” or the ubiquitous images of kids with drawn-in dunce hats (and that’s only on the first page).
Now before you throw your
Fiskars implements at me, please know that my post is meant as a sincere attempt to engage all of you in a constructive discussion about collage and scrapbooking. Although the latter may not be my cup of tea, I have nothing against those of you who love and practice this artform. In fact, more power to you for being creative! However, I would like us to be honest and talk about issues that so far have gone unexplored for the most part. I really encourage you to participate in this discussion.
Although both collage and scrapbooking share similar materials and techniques and are highly addictive activities with definite fringe benefits *smile*, they are different at their core. While scrapbooking stems from a
genteel tradition of journaling and ephemera, collage burst on the art scene as a revolutionary art form. As both evolved, scrapbooking remained true to its nostalgic themes but managed to morph into a
mega $2.5+ billion industry. Traditional cut-and-paste collage, on the other hand, stuck to its avant-garde origins while painstakingly struggling to establish itself as a legitimate art form. The differences do not stop here, I think.
Collage art is all about individuality, innovation, risk-taking and creativity. As in any other artistic endeavor, this means going deep into yourself and exploring what makes you who you are. Whether your art is expressionist or abstract, the core motivation is still the same: creating artistic meaning as individual as we are. It also means stretching the limits and going beyond what seems safe and/or familiar. Some scrapbookers do follow these guidelines and their art is truly delightful. A few though seem to hesitate and prefer to stick to standardized imagery and themes. And that’s a pity I think, because given the infinite possibilities available, it would be a shame not to take a few risks here and there (spending half your paycheck on a couple of
Jimmy Choo slingbacks is not an option though).
Whether you want to buy scrapbooking or collage supplies by the truckload, it’s up to you. The main thing is to be creative and have a clear purpose in your artistic pursuits. In other words, make what you do meaningful to you. If putting a clown hat on a favorite image is significant to you, then by all means do it. Otherwise, you may want to ask yourself some important, albeit difficult, questions about what you are trying to do and where you might be going with all this. It is not my intention to rain on anyone’s parade here but to invite kindred spirits in exploring potential ways to attain higher levels of creativity and a deeper sense of achievement and satisfaction. I struggle with these issues every day and I would really like to hear what you think.
If I were to summarize my collage aesthetics, it would start with the following ideas:
1.Make art that ten years from now will still be of value to you personally.
2. Invest in yourself and your ideas.
3. Create mindfully.
4.Trust your instincts.
5. Free yourself from constraints imposed by yourself or others.
6. Liberate your creativity from the confines of marketed art. Find free and unexpected sources of inspiration around you.
7. Challenge – yes challenge!—everything you have learned so far (be it from books, workshops, friends, etc.)
8. Separate yourself from the crowd.
9. Dig into your own past and present and discover your own narrative. Create your own personal myths, imagery, and personal meaning.
10. Put aside the familiar and open the door. You will be pleasantly surprised!
Now, it’s your turn!